India Future Society

Maintaining Physical Continuity While Achieving Digital Immortality

by BJ Murphy

Jul 10, 13 • Body Enhancement6 CommentsRead More »

digital-lateralization[1]During our current technological age of the 21st century, topics like robotics, AI, mind uploading, and indefinite life extension are no longer topics of science-fiction, but rather of science-facts and possibilities. The most common one being heavily debated at the current moment is mind uploading. Once we’re able to artificially replicate the human brain, and then begin uploading ourselves into said artificial brain, will we lose consciousness? Will we still be ourselves or will we simply create a copy? Is it a risk we’re willing to take?

I love life. And so the prospect of indefinite life extension is very attractive, IMO. Then again, seeing as how I wish to live much longer than my biologically-fixed clock dictates, to simply make a copy of myself to live forever, but not actually myself, just doesn’t cut it. I would never destroy my brain and let someone else be me for me. If I’m to achieve indefinite life extension, then I want to do so with both my physical and functional continuity still in complete operation. Without one, the other is completely irrelevant.

What is physical and functional continuity? Functional continuity is basically the stream of consciousness which makes you…well…you. “Destroying” functional continuity wouldn’t necessarily do anything to you, nor would it remain destroyed, per se. When we’re going through REM sleep every night, our functional continuity fluctuates on and off, only to be completely restored the next morning. Yes, your consciousness before sleep was different from the consciousness you now acquire after sleep, but you remain yourself – you’re still self-aware. The same applies when getting surgery, thus knocked out due to anesthesia. Only this time, your functional continuity is turned completely off. There is no streaming of consciousness. And yet, after the surgery, your functional continuity turns back on, unaffected insofar as you remain self-aware.

So what about physical continuity? Physical continuity is very important – much more important than functional continuity. Physical continuity – using as simple an understanding as possible – is essentially the brain and all of its synaptic operations. To destroy physical continuity would be to destroy the brain. Thus destroying everything, including the functional continuity which comes along with it. Reason being why physical continuity should be highly looked after much more so than functional continuity. You can destroy your functional continuity and still have the chance to regain it so long physical continuity remains intact. The contrary, however, would be the end of yourself in its entirety.

Thus bringing us to our current dilemma of mind uploading. How are we to achieve mind uploading without destroying physical continuity in the process? To simply “download” everything within your brain and upload it into an artificial brain, while functional continuity is being streamed, physical continuity is being replicated, not maintained. Essentially you’d be partaking in a really cool process of cloning. That’s it. Think of Lt Cmdr Data and his brother Lore from the Star Trek universe (ignoring, of course, your cloned self being a maniacal psychopath).

Christina Santhouse

Christina Santhouse

Which brings me to our current understanding of what is known as “Brain Lateralization” – the two cerebral hemispheres of the brain, separated by a longitudinal fissure. In other words, the left and right brain. Both are almost complete replicas to one another. Which we’ve since discovered that, if you’re to destroy one side of the brain, the other side should remain functional, thus maintaining relative normalcy. A great example of this would be now-twenty-six-year-old Christina Santhouse, who suffered from Rasmussen’s encephalitis – a neurological disease which causes seizures and the loss of motor skills. (http://abcn.ws/12nyCtp) Once she began having over 100 seizures a day at such a young age, her and her family decided to take on a radical approach to address this very serious problem – take out the side of the brain causing this disease. The result? She’s now a normal young woman, earning a scholarship to Misericordia University under a speech-language pathology major! (http://bit.ly/171ay4a)

Why is this important? Because, IMO, it paves the way in understanding how to maintain physical continuity while subsequently uploading your mind into an artificial brain. Imagine going through a process of downloading your entire brain and its various synaptic operations – including consciousness, functional continuity. Then you upload it into an artificially designed right hemisphere of the brain. Now let’s say that you have an operation which replaces your right hemisphere of your biological brain for the artificial replica, all while keeping your left hemisphere completely intact. Over time, the right artificial hemisphere would become the dominant hemisphere, especially once your left biological hemisphere dies. So not only would you have then maintained functional continuity, but also physical continuity as well. You would achieve indefinite life extension via “digital immortality”, per se.

This is the only way I can think of which will allow us to achieve both without losing one or the other in the process.

Tags: ,

6 Responses to Maintaining Physical Continuity While Achieving Digital Immortality

  1. So, explain what you think happens if you duplicate *both* hemispheres from your brain, separate each and therefore have a “transfer” of both the left and the right brain as *two* separate (artificial) brains. Which is a simple logical extension of this line of argument. You could either do this concurrently, i.e. whilst the original, organic, brain exists or at a time subsequent to the death of the biological material.

    Also, study Rupert Sheldrake http://www.sheldrake.org

  2. Tim Gross says:

    any form of destructive uploading or radical cyberization will never happen anyway- not because they cannot be done- they can- and not because they might generate a copy instead of preserving the original- identity is memory is the soul- so any copies are originals- the reason why this philosophical debate will never be tested is because any such procedure would be a medical procedure- and all medical procedures down to toenail removal are regulated by governments- governments that have unwaveringly prohibited elective augmentation- this means that becoming an immortal human cyborg will have to be DIY- and the only non-surgical way to do that is through personal fabrication of nanodrugs and food supplements that allow an individual to replace/augment their brains and bodies one cell at a time by hijacking metabolism with biomemetic nanotechnology-

    • Phaedrus Buxiu says:

      What would prevent a transhumanist group with investors from doing these types of experimental procedures in, say, the Bahamas, or any nearby state without relevantly explicit laws? If the volunteer would otherwise die in the short-term and is apprised of the risks, it seems intuitively ethical to me, and conservatively-speaking at least marginally better than assisted suicide.

  3. kusanageek says:

    Another way of doing so could be to apply the “Von Neumann probes” idea to the brain with nanotechnologies in order to replace neurons with a better substrate gradually while still being conscious.

    It shouldn’t be any different to us than any change your brain goes through every day if it can be done (hopefully).

  4. […] UPDATE: My following article below was just re-published by the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies (IEET) and India Future Society. […]

  5. Rui Barbosa says:

    Something totally outside of this debate is that what constitutes our life is not our Consciousness (a product of the Brain) but our SOUL! And our Soul is an inner spirit which animates all our life,on Earth and in Eternal Life. And that spirit, as well as all spirits, cannot be manipulated nor transfered by by Man to a Robot…

Leave a Reply

Read previous post:
Want to Live Indefinitely Again After Death? Try Cryonic Freezing! Part 2

Continuing from the previous article Neuropreservation Neuropreservation is cryopreservation within the brain with surgical procedures used to remove the rest of the body,...

Close